biographiesofFranzKafka

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, 6 May 2013

No Mr. Umari, Shahbagh Is No Imperialist Conspiracy - Subhash Gatade

Posted on 01:48 by Unknown
GUWAHATI: The echo of the Shahbag protest in Bangladesh was heard about 200 miles away here on Sunday with citizens, under the banner of Janamat, expressing solidarity with protesters in that country. Janamat, a Guwahati-based socio-cultural body which organised the solidarity meet here, said that the issue raised by the Shahbag protesters is relevant to India in general and Assam in particular because both the countries' secular and democratic fabrics are threatened by communal forces.

       Solidarity meet in city for Shahbag protest. Times News Network, April 29, 2013 

Representatives of different Gonojagoron Mancha across the country on Friday suggested spreading its activities to grassroots level to aware people about its demands. They urged all to be united to fight against Jamaat-Shibir and move forward with a view to realising their demands …Around 300 representatives from 167 gonojagoron manchas from seven divisions attended the daylong representative conference at Senate Bhaban of Dhaka University to express their views and suggestions to strengthen the movement. 

Imran H Sarkar, spokesperson for the Gonojagoron Mancha, announced a mass rally at Mymensingh on May 18 and a grand rally at Projonmo Chattar in Dhaka on May 31 at the end of the conference. 
                                                                                       The Daily Star, May 3, 2013 
I
Maulana Syed Jalaluddin Umari, President of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, (Born in 1935), seems to be a learned man, at least that's what his biographical details tell us. Elected for the second time as Ameer (President) of the Jamaat he is known to have 'authored more than thirty books' and is 'considered an 'authority on human rights in general, and women and Islamic family system in particular'. Interestingly, despite his long innings in social-political life and exposure to the outside world his understanding of some crucial developments in this part of the subcontinent seems to be at variance from what can be said as a general consensus around the issue. 

The manner in which he and the organisation he leads reacted to the recent developments in Bangladesh, the emergence of what is known as Shahbagh movement - the spontaneous movement initiated by youth seeking 'exemplary punishment to the war criminals' and banning of 'politics based on religion' - is an indicative of this disconnect between what Maulana Umari and the organisation he leads thinks and what actually happened. 

As everybody knows the question of trial of 'war criminals' in Bangladesh's liberation struggle still remains unsettled, despite the fact that it has been a longstanding demand of the Bangladeshi people who faced genocide at the hands of Pakistani army. The support rendered to them in this venture by local activists of Jamaat-e-Islami belonging to then East Pakistan is another ignoble aspect of this whole episode. The way post-liberation history of Bangladesh unfolded itself, where one witnessed assassination of Sheikh Mujibur Rehman, towering leader of the liberation struggle and the first prime minister of the newly independent country, followed by coups and a period of instability, this important task could not be addressed. Yes, time and again there were attempts at the non-official level to underline and emphasise this unfinished task : e.g. Way back in 1992, an organisation led by Jahanara Imam ( called Shaheed Janani - mother of martyrs) called ' Ekattorer Ghatak-Dalal Nirmul Committee’ had held mock public trial of people accused of war crimes in a People’s Court. The immediate context of having this trial was that Gulam Azam, whose citizenship was revoked by Sheikh Mujib, was elected as the Amir of the Jamaat-e-Islami. The High Court, however, in 1993 restored his citizenship which was later upheld by the Bangladesh Supreme Court in 1994. 

These attempts received a boost when Awami League under the leadership of Sheikh Haseena returned to power (2009) and set up an International War Crimes Tribunal to try some leading activists of Jamaat-e-Islami, Bangladesh and Bangladesh Nationalist Party as part of fulfillment of its electoral promise. Critics also see it as an attempt to claim legacy over the historic struggle for liberation. A War Crimes Fact Finding Committee in April 2010 published a list of 1597 suspects. As far as evidence to be presented during the trial, the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973 states: “A Tribunal shall not be bound by technical rules of evidence; and it shall adopt and apply to the greatest possible extent expeditious and non-technical procedure, and may admit any evidence, including reports and photographs published in newspapers, perio-dicals and magazines, film and tape-recordings and other materials as may be tendered before it, which it deems to have probative value.” (As cited in Julfiqar Ali Manik, “The Trial we are Still Waiting For”, Forum, Daily Star, 3(12), December 2009.

The flashpoint of this three month old youth led movement became the 'lenient punishment' meted out to Vice President of Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh, Abdul Quader Mollah, who was given life sentence on February 5 in spite of his proven guilt of the heinous crimes that he had committed. He was proven guilty on five counts out of six charges that were brought against him, including murdering more than 300 people. The photo of this man emerging from the court, smiling and making a Victory sign, so infuriated the youth that they gave a call on social network to gather at the historic Shahbagh Square. Rest is now history. (5 th Feb 2013) 

On 20 June 1971, Ghulam Azam at a press conference at Lahore Airport said, “With support from many non-Muslims in East Pakistan, Sheik Mujib intends for secession. (Pakistan) Army has uprooted almost all miscreants from East Pakistan and now there is no power which can challenge the dominance of the army”.  ..On August 12, 1971, Azam declared, “the supporters of the so-called Bangladesh Movement are the enemies of Islam, Pakistan, and Muslims”.  ..On 5 August 1971, Matiur Rahman Nizami (then head of Al Badr) said “Allah entrusted the pious Muslims with the responsibility to save His beloved Pakistan. (But) when the Muslims failed to solve the political problem in a political way, then Allah saved His beloved land through the (Pakistan) army”. (Courtesy:Daily Prothom Alo, 11 January 2012, a compilation of statements based on what was published in Jamaat’s own newspaper The Daily Sangram in 1971)

As has been written elsewhere, the uniqueness of the Shahdbagh movement - as hundreds of thousands of people from all walks of life converged in this important part of Dhaka and continued to demonstrate for weeks together - was that though it was principally initiated by those youth who run online blogs, and none of whom had actually witnessed the actual genocide, it quickly witnessed the participation of other classes. People could see the repetition of ‘Tahrir Square’ in Dhaka, but not many could foresee that it went much beyond. Undoubtedly, by taking lead in this historic movement and persisting against heavy odds, the youth of Bangladesh were trying to carry forward the forgotten legacy of all those unnamed martyrs who sacrificed their present for a better future for the people of Bangladesh - a future free of religious extremism, a future guaranteeing a life of dignity to everyone.

Forget words of appreciation for this historic churning in our neighbourhood, and the youth's resolve to set right 'historical wrongs' happened more than four decades ago and their attempts to bring to book the 'war criminals' who were responsible for indiscriminate killings of innocents - which included people belonging to different faiths or political outlook - and rapes of women, during the struggle for liberation; forget the fact that people on this part of the border had once played a very supportive role for their struggle, Maulana Umari had nothing but scorn for these young fighters and it appeared that he was trying every way to sanitise the crimes of the Bangladeshi Jamaatis. He lamented : "the death sentence for popular leader of Bangladesh Jamaat Islami Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and renowned religious leader and speaker Maulana Dilawar Husain Sayeedi by the ruling Awami League-appointed war tribunal. While terming the conviction as cruelty and injustice, Maulana Umari demanded Bangladesh government to revoke the sentence against Sayeedi and all leaders of Jamaat Islami, rescind the cases and release them. He said this punishment is the worst example of devaluing the nation’s most caring and concerned Jamaat and its people. Those who have observed international affairs and politics know well that Bangladesh Jamaat Islami did great service to the nation in the field of religion, politics, economy and social welfare..." 

The glorification of Jamaatis in Bangladesh did not end at that. And this despite the fact that all historical evidence pointed to the contrary, which again and again underlined the criminal role played by them during the war of liberation. read more:

http://nsi-delhi.blogspot.in/2013/05/shahbagh-no-imperialist-conspiracy-mr.html#more

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Bangladesh, communalism, Global War and Violence, history | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home
View mobile version

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Book review: The Frankfurt School at War - the Marxists Who Explained the Nazis to Washington
    Secret Reports on Nazi Germany: The Frankfurt School Contribution to the War Effort ,  by FRANZ NEUMANN, HERBERT MARCUSE, and OTTO KIRCHHEIM...
  • Al Worden: ‘The loneliest human being’
    What’s it like to be the most isolated human in all eternity? BBC space correspondent meets Al Worden, command module pilot of Apollo 15, wh...
  • Academic reforms and DU's circus of reason
    हम होंगे baccalaureate  हम होंगे baccalaureate  Associate baccalaureate  एक दिन हमे VC में है विश्वास पूरा है विश्वास हम होंगे baccalaureate...
  • VIJAY PRASHAD: Mr. Modi Wants to Come to America
    ... Modi has been at the helm in that state since 2001. The following year, in 2002, Modi presided over the mass killing of Muslims by his p...
  • Atheist Siddaramaiah and God's changing role in politics
    K. Siddaramaiah, a rare Indian politician who wears his atheism on his sleeve, took the oath as the next chief minister of Karnataka on Mond...
  • Kabita Chakma: Sexual violence, indigenous Jumma women & Chittagong Hill Tracts, Bangladesh
    There has been a high rate of violence against women all over Bangladesh in recent years. Kapaeeng Foundation figures for January 2007 to De...
  • The Act of Killing is being hailed by critics as one of the best films of the year
    'You celebrate mass killing so you don't have to look yourself in the mirror'  Joshua Oppenheimer went to Indonesia to make a d...
  • PAUL KRUGMAN - Hitting China’s Wall
    All economic data are best viewed as a peculiarly boring genre of science fiction, but Chinese data are even more fictional than most. Add a...
  • अयोध्या : तीन पीढ़ियां तीन दृष्टिकोण - के पी सिंह, फैजाबाद
    जन्नतनशीन रहीमुल्ला के एक दिसम्बर, 1936 को पैदा हुए बेटे लाल मोहम्मद 22-23 दिसम्बर, 1949 की उस रात के गिने-चुने प्रत्यक्षदर्शियों में से हैं...
  • MURTAZA HAIDER - Islam at war – with itself
    Muslim societies have thus evolved into places where revenge is confused with justice, forgiveness with weakness, and peace with cowardice. ...

Categories

  • A K Ramanujan's Three Hundred Ramayanas (1)
  • Afghanistan (7)
  • Africa (9)
  • Ahimsa (17)
  • animals (2)
  • Art (4)
  • Astronomy (9)
  • Bangladesh (23)
  • birds (5)
  • Books and literature (40)
  • Burma (4)
  • CARTOONS (2)
  • censorship (33)
  • childhood (15)
  • China (23)
  • communalism (85)
  • corruption (24)
  • critical theory (34)
  • current affairs - India (139)
  • current affairs - international (51)
  • democratic protest (40)
  • Dilip's notes and articles (6)
  • ecology (36)
  • economics (23)
  • education (14)
  • energy (2)
  • Evolution (2)
  • films (3)
  • Global War and Violence (52)
  • history (81)
  • human rights (89)
  • Indian culture (13)
  • Japan (2)
  • justice (100)
  • labour matters (27)
  • media (26)
  • medicine (6)
  • Middle East (27)
  • mining (13)
  • music (2)
  • naxalism (20)
  • Nepal (2)
  • Obituary (6)
  • organised crime (30)
  • Pakistan (30)
  • Palestine / Israel (5)
  • Partition related texts (3)
  • philosophy (10)
  • Photos (16)
  • Poetry (2)
  • religion (23)
  • Russia (10)
  • Sampradayikta Virodhi Andolan (2)
  • satire (2)
  • science (20)
  • short stories (2)
  • Social networking (8)
  • Sri Lanka (2)
  • the human mind (36)
  • the oceans (6)
  • thinking about fascism (68)
  • Tibet (3)
  • women's rights (32)
  • Workers' movements (9)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  August (29)
    • ►  July (119)
    • ►  June (133)
    • ▼  May (114)
      • Subhash Gatade: HINDUTVA IN KARNATAKA - EXPERIMENT...
      • Germany fears revolution if Europe scraps welfare ...
      • Turkish police fire tear gas in worst protests in ...
      • Turkey: Ruling party member calls for the ‘annihil...
      • Pervez Hoodbhoy: PAKISTAN: WHY THEY KILLED ARIF SH...
      • Book review: Time Regained!
      • Khmer Rouge leaders say sorry for atrocities
      • Collateral damage? Maoists say sorry for killing B...
      • Aruna Roy resigns from National Advisory Council
      • HEATHER MCROBIE - What sex means for world peace
      • Ritwik Agrawal: Mannequin Lingerie Ban in Mumbai –...
      • Raymond Tallis - Philosophy isn't dead yet
      • PUCL Condemns Killings by Maoists // NAPM Condemns...
      • RAMACHANDRA GUHA - The continuing tragedy of the a...
      • The Last of the World War I Vets Speak
      • Moonrise from Space By Phil Plait
      • Pak agencies behind the killing of Arif Shahid: KN...
      • The Futility of Common Sense: An Essay on Ahimsa
      • Book on Mahatma Gandhi released in China
      • The Secrets of Easter Island
      • SHIRIN EBADI - The framework of democracy is human...
      • Ndeye Marie Thiam - Women of Senegal: agents of peace
      • Why Fire Makes Us Human
      • Zahi Hawass - the supreme chief of Egypt’s antiqui...
      • Dark matter - Lisa Randall’s Guide to the Galaxy
      • Quantum Magnetism Observed For First Time, Physici...
      • On the Salwa Judum (2008)
      • Himanshu Kumar: Remembering Mahendra Karma, the fo...
      • Himanshu Kumar: दरभा घाटी में अभी एक दुर्घटना हुई ...
      • NAPM Condemns the Ambush by Maoists in Bastar
      • Tunisian feminist blogger Amina Tyler jailed
      • Chile's Indians take on world's largest gold minin...
      • JAMAL KIDWAI: A History Lesson
      • The DU Vice Chancellor is a tyrant on the rampage/...
      • Mother-of-two confronted Woolwich attackers, thoug...
      • Archaeologists uncover nearly 5,000 cave paintings...
      • Violence continues in Stockholm as Swedish rioting...
      • Daniel Dennett, a cheerleader for Darwin and athei...
      • Facebook's violently sexist pages are an opportuni...
      • Iran's prisoners of conscience
      • Theodor Adorno - Education After Auschwitz (1966)
      • Campaigners in China challenge authorities over en...
      • Full Moon Over (it's beauteous enough to make you ...
      • MEREDITH TAX - Unpacking the idea of “Islamophobia”
      • MAIREAD MAGUIRE: Building a culture of love: repla...
      • Nayanjot Lahiri: History as a utility toolkit
      • A K Ramanujan works dropped from new DU syllabus
      • Stop Police Brutality Against Maruti Suzuki Workers
      • Meredith Tax on the changing status of Afghan wome...
      • NAPM strongly condemns the arrest of Madhuri Krish...
      • Maria Popova: Mark Twain and Rudyard Kipling Criti...
      • Greek addicts turn to deadly shisha drug as econom...
      • Earth And Sky Photo Contest 2013 Winners Revealed ...
      • How Varun Gandhi silenced the system - Tehelka expose
      • Nazes Afroz: Afghanistan after 2014
      • Electoral terrorism wins … for now - Masud Alam on...
      • China tries to rein in micro-bloggers for dissemin...
      • British male identity crisis 'spurring machismo an...
      • Chris Hadfield's photographs of Earth from space
      • Shekhar Gupta on Pakistan's elections: Allah and A...
      • Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case: CBI books ...
      • Atheist Siddaramaiah and God's changing role in po...
      • Book review: Albert Hirschman - An Original Thinke...
      • Climate Change To Shrink Animal And Plant Habitats...
      • Gatsby's heartbreaker: F. Scott Fitzgerald's self-...
      • Book review: Albert Camus‘ 'Algerian Chronicles’ /...
      • Judith Butler - ‘I affirm a Judaism that is not as...
      • Book review: A differing shade of green: Neolibera...
      • Michael Sandel and AC Grayling on markets, morals ...
      • Efrain Rios Montt, Former Guatemalan Dictator, Con...
      • Atmospheric CO2 Concentrations Highest ever in hum...
      • Putin’s war patriotism
      • Garga Chatterjee - Religious imperialism at the he...
      • Public Meeting on Shahbagh Movement: A beacon of h...
      • Pervez Hoodbhoy: Scientists & an atomic subcontine...
      • Ishrat Jahan encounter case: Cops protecting accus...
      • Modi’s Pals: CAG report indicts Gujarat government...
      • Godhra Investigations
      • Bansal or Mamata, top rail job postings reek of ir...
      • India's Child Soldiers: Thousands recruited, Gover...
      • Notes from the frontline of the war in cyberspace
      • Over 900 victims; Dhaka disaster world’s worst in ...
      • Seema Sirohi: As historic elections dawn, public m...
      • Pratap Bhanu Mehta - Phantom democracy
      • Pakistani prisoner Sanaullah Ranjay, who was attac...
      • Three more Tibetans self-immolate
      • A Muslim woman and a Brahmin widow
      • Exclusive interview with Noam Chomsky on Pakistan ...
      • Book review: The identity question - comment on Se...
      • Stephen Hawking joins academic boycott of Israel
      • Tariq Ali - 1963: from the Stones to Dr Strangelov...
      • 'An honest Minister keeps the Railways honest'
      • Narendra Modi magic fails in Karnataka
      • Aarti Tikoo Singh's extended interview with Tarek ...
      • Book review: The trouble with the Enlightenment
      • US Air Force Officer In Charge Of Sexual Assault P...
      • An open letter on undertrials: Adivasis need speed...
      • US panel wants Modi included on lookout list besid...
      • No Mr. Umari, Shahbagh Is No Imperialist Conspirac...
      • 22 dead as Bangladesh Islamists demand blasphemy l...
    • ►  April (100)
    • ►  March (5)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile