biographiesofFranzKafka

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Saturday, 18 May 2013

Meredith Tax on the changing status of Afghan women in America's priorities

Posted on 21:57 by Unknown
People Who Live in Glass Houses Shouldn't Throw Pet Rocks
If one can assume that the foreign news coverage of The New York Times is reflective of the (sometimes conflicting) views of the US government, what can we learn from its coverage of Afganistan?  Saturday’s headline tells of a “wave of violence” sweeping Afghanistan—two dozen people, including a police chief, were killed by Taliban bombs in the last few days.  In the last month, coverage has also included US-Afghan talks on future relations; untold bags of CIA cash for Karzai; other Taliban attacks on civilians; and mixed messages on the “transition.” And what about Afghan women and civil society? 
 
No news, and no surprise if we remember the anonymous senior State Department official who told the Washington Post in 2011, “Gender issues are going to have to take a back seat to other priorities.  There's no way we can be successful if we maintain every special interest and pet project. All those pet rocks in our rucksack were taking us down.” Remember those words when people tell you the reason the US invaded Afghanistan was to rescue Afghan women. 
 
Oh, baby, all these years we’ve been together and all I am to you is a pet rock? 
 
Looming on the horizon are disastrous changes to the Violence Against Women act—one of the few proud achievements of the occupation, even if  seldom enforced.  The  Elimination of Violence Against Women act was a decree made by President Karzai in 2009; it never came before Parliament.  This week Fawzia Koofi, an MP who is running for President, brought the law into Parliament- and Afghan women into the Times - despite the fact that the lower house is dominated by stone reactionaries and many Afghan feminists opposed the idea.  The Afghan Women’s Network called a press conference to warn against the move on May 16 and sent out this letter to friends overseas:
 
For those of you who are following the controversy over the Elimination of Violence against Women Law (EVAW) which was enacted in 2009 through a decree of President.  The law was developed through an organic movement of women of Afghanistan 2005-2009. In today’s Parliament session the law was reviewed as anti (islamic) Shariah and was reverted to the commissions of the parliament [I.e. sent to committee] to have close scrutiny of the law from Islamic Shariah before voting in general assembly.
 
The EVAW law has been considered a major step forward in the legal protection of women’s rights in last 12 years.  EVAW law criminalizes child marriage, forced marriage, selling and buying of women for the purpose or under the pretext of marriage, ba’ad (giving away a woman or girl to settle a dispute), forced self-immolation and 17 other acts of violence against women including rape and beating.  

Since last two years civil society organization including human rights network, Afghan Women Network, Afghan Civil society forum and Human rights Commission has reached the women commission of Parliament under Ms. Koofi to be realistic to the situation in Parliament and lay down her effort for bringing the law in agenda of parliament. 

 
The concerns of civil society had been twofold. A, while EVAW is already is officially gazetted and legally enforced, other efforts is only reinvention of the wheel and waste of resources and time.  B, most importantly that  law can bear high risk of weakening and rejection considering the conservative environment inside Afghan Parliament
The highlight of Today's session of Parliament are:
  • The  Parliament called EVAW law a bill that is anti Shariah and insisted that the President of Afghanistan should be questioned for his act of going against Islamic Shariah endorsing this law 3 years back
  • That the law should go back to commissions of Parliament [committee] for Islamic Shariah review
  • The law cannot be taken out of the agenda of Parliament as there are efforts to safeguard women’s rights as per foreign culture
  • The members of the commission complained that 6 articles that they have serious concern about are not in the copy presented in Parliament
  1. The definition of violence including wife beating is  encouraging  disruption of harmony while husband according to Islamic Shariah has the right to discipline the wife
  2. Father and guardian knows better privileges and benefit of children therefore child marriage through guardian cannot be questioned as per this law
  3. Shelter homes [shelters for women fleeing abuse] are un-Islamic and centers of prostitution, therefore should be closed immediately
  4. Arranged marriage with support of parents cannot be considered forced marriage
These concerns have been well known from the beginning through an independent analysis of UNAMA and civil society; however the transparency of the process and accountability of Women Commission of Parliament can be questioned for bringing the conviction that everything is rosy in Parliament and labeling civic movement for the protection of the law as part of political controversy of her opponents.
Now that genuine concern of Afghan Civil society is clear, there is need of serious attention of international interlocutors in Afghanistan towards protection of the law; as Afghan Women’s Network press statement (16 May) warns “…this will be beginning of the decline of women’s rights in Afghanistan.”

So over to you, “international interlocutors in Afghanistan.”  You have spent all the time and money in the world on military solutions that haven’t solved anything.  How about trying some political solutions?  How about strengthening civil society instead of putting all your money into drones, weapons, bases and Karzai's pocket?  How about defending women’s human rights?

Or are such civilian concerns just another bunch of pet rocks to you?
http://www.meredithtax.org/taxonomyblog/people-who-live-glass-houses-shouldnt-throw-pet-rocks
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Afghanistan, Global War and Violence, human rights, women's rights | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Media & police ducking the question of Hindutva terror
    From: The Hindu, June 10, 2013 Accusing sections of the media and the police of deliberately ignoring the issue of Hindutva extremism, journ...
  • Book review: The Frankfurt School at War - the Marxists Who Explained the Nazis to Washington
    Secret Reports on Nazi Germany: The Frankfurt School Contribution to the War Effort ,  by FRANZ NEUMANN, HERBERT MARCUSE, and OTTO KIRCHHEIM...
  • Books Reviewed: TWO NEW BOOKS ABOUT “BORGES”
    Few artists have built grand structures on such uncertain foundations as Jorge Luis Borges. Doubt was the sacred principle of his work, its ...
  • Karima Bennoune on Islamofascism in Algeria: Twenty years on, words do not die
    This year marks the twentieth anniversary of the Algerian jihadists war on culture. Those who waged the intellectual struggle against fundam...
  • Chris Hadfield's photographs of Earth from space
    During his 5 months in space on board the International Space Station, Commander Chris Hadfield has gained 790,000 followers on Twitter than...
  • Pravin Sawhney: Subtle Chinese ping-pong
    A Chinese border guards' platoon (40 soldiers) has pitched tents ten kilometres inside Indian territory overlooking Daulet Beg Oldie (DB...
  • Kabita Chakma: Sexual violence, indigenous Jumma women & Chittagong Hill Tracts, Bangladesh
    There has been a high rate of violence against women all over Bangladesh in recent years. Kapaeeng Foundation figures for January 2007 to De...
  • Atheist Siddaramaiah and God's changing role in politics
    K. Siddaramaiah, a rare Indian politician who wears his atheism on his sleeve, took the oath as the next chief minister of Karnataka on Mond...
  • Child labour & low wages at Dutch seed companies
    Two Dutch vegetable seed companies in India compared * Combating child labour: active involvement makes the difference * Hazardous child lab...
  • The Act of Killing is being hailed by critics as one of the best films of the year
    'You celebrate mass killing so you don't have to look yourself in the mirror'  Joshua Oppenheimer went to Indonesia to make a d...

Categories

  • A K Ramanujan's Three Hundred Ramayanas (1)
  • Afghanistan (7)
  • Africa (9)
  • Ahimsa (17)
  • animals (2)
  • Art (4)
  • Astronomy (9)
  • Bangladesh (23)
  • birds (5)
  • Books and literature (40)
  • Burma (4)
  • CARTOONS (2)
  • censorship (33)
  • childhood (15)
  • China (23)
  • communalism (85)
  • corruption (24)
  • critical theory (34)
  • current affairs - India (139)
  • current affairs - international (51)
  • democratic protest (40)
  • Dilip's notes and articles (6)
  • ecology (36)
  • economics (23)
  • education (14)
  • energy (2)
  • Evolution (2)
  • films (3)
  • Global War and Violence (52)
  • history (81)
  • human rights (89)
  • Indian culture (13)
  • Japan (2)
  • justice (100)
  • labour matters (27)
  • media (26)
  • medicine (6)
  • Middle East (27)
  • mining (13)
  • music (2)
  • naxalism (20)
  • Nepal (2)
  • Obituary (6)
  • organised crime (30)
  • Pakistan (30)
  • Palestine / Israel (5)
  • Partition related texts (3)
  • philosophy (10)
  • Photos (16)
  • Poetry (2)
  • religion (23)
  • Russia (10)
  • Sampradayikta Virodhi Andolan (2)
  • satire (2)
  • science (20)
  • short stories (2)
  • Social networking (8)
  • Sri Lanka (2)
  • the human mind (36)
  • the oceans (6)
  • thinking about fascism (68)
  • Tibet (3)
  • women's rights (32)
  • Workers' movements (9)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  August (29)
    • ►  July (119)
    • ►  June (133)
    • ▼  May (114)
      • Subhash Gatade: HINDUTVA IN KARNATAKA - EXPERIMENT...
      • Germany fears revolution if Europe scraps welfare ...
      • Turkish police fire tear gas in worst protests in ...
      • Turkey: Ruling party member calls for the ‘annihil...
      • Pervez Hoodbhoy: PAKISTAN: WHY THEY KILLED ARIF SH...
      • Book review: Time Regained!
      • Khmer Rouge leaders say sorry for atrocities
      • Collateral damage? Maoists say sorry for killing B...
      • Aruna Roy resigns from National Advisory Council
      • HEATHER MCROBIE - What sex means for world peace
      • Ritwik Agrawal: Mannequin Lingerie Ban in Mumbai –...
      • Raymond Tallis - Philosophy isn't dead yet
      • PUCL Condemns Killings by Maoists // NAPM Condemns...
      • RAMACHANDRA GUHA - The continuing tragedy of the a...
      • The Last of the World War I Vets Speak
      • Moonrise from Space By Phil Plait
      • Pak agencies behind the killing of Arif Shahid: KN...
      • The Futility of Common Sense: An Essay on Ahimsa
      • Book on Mahatma Gandhi released in China
      • The Secrets of Easter Island
      • SHIRIN EBADI - The framework of democracy is human...
      • Ndeye Marie Thiam - Women of Senegal: agents of peace
      • Why Fire Makes Us Human
      • Zahi Hawass - the supreme chief of Egypt’s antiqui...
      • Dark matter - Lisa Randall’s Guide to the Galaxy
      • Quantum Magnetism Observed For First Time, Physici...
      • On the Salwa Judum (2008)
      • Himanshu Kumar: Remembering Mahendra Karma, the fo...
      • Himanshu Kumar: दरभा घाटी में अभी एक दुर्घटना हुई ...
      • NAPM Condemns the Ambush by Maoists in Bastar
      • Tunisian feminist blogger Amina Tyler jailed
      • Chile's Indians take on world's largest gold minin...
      • JAMAL KIDWAI: A History Lesson
      • The DU Vice Chancellor is a tyrant on the rampage/...
      • Mother-of-two confronted Woolwich attackers, thoug...
      • Archaeologists uncover nearly 5,000 cave paintings...
      • Violence continues in Stockholm as Swedish rioting...
      • Daniel Dennett, a cheerleader for Darwin and athei...
      • Facebook's violently sexist pages are an opportuni...
      • Iran's prisoners of conscience
      • Theodor Adorno - Education After Auschwitz (1966)
      • Campaigners in China challenge authorities over en...
      • Full Moon Over (it's beauteous enough to make you ...
      • MEREDITH TAX - Unpacking the idea of “Islamophobia”
      • MAIREAD MAGUIRE: Building a culture of love: repla...
      • Nayanjot Lahiri: History as a utility toolkit
      • A K Ramanujan works dropped from new DU syllabus
      • Stop Police Brutality Against Maruti Suzuki Workers
      • Meredith Tax on the changing status of Afghan wome...
      • NAPM strongly condemns the arrest of Madhuri Krish...
      • Maria Popova: Mark Twain and Rudyard Kipling Criti...
      • Greek addicts turn to deadly shisha drug as econom...
      • Earth And Sky Photo Contest 2013 Winners Revealed ...
      • How Varun Gandhi silenced the system - Tehelka expose
      • Nazes Afroz: Afghanistan after 2014
      • Electoral terrorism wins … for now - Masud Alam on...
      • China tries to rein in micro-bloggers for dissemin...
      • British male identity crisis 'spurring machismo an...
      • Chris Hadfield's photographs of Earth from space
      • Shekhar Gupta on Pakistan's elections: Allah and A...
      • Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case: CBI books ...
      • Atheist Siddaramaiah and God's changing role in po...
      • Book review: Albert Hirschman - An Original Thinke...
      • Climate Change To Shrink Animal And Plant Habitats...
      • Gatsby's heartbreaker: F. Scott Fitzgerald's self-...
      • Book review: Albert Camus‘ 'Algerian Chronicles’ /...
      • Judith Butler - ‘I affirm a Judaism that is not as...
      • Book review: A differing shade of green: Neolibera...
      • Michael Sandel and AC Grayling on markets, morals ...
      • Efrain Rios Montt, Former Guatemalan Dictator, Con...
      • Atmospheric CO2 Concentrations Highest ever in hum...
      • Putin’s war patriotism
      • Garga Chatterjee - Religious imperialism at the he...
      • Public Meeting on Shahbagh Movement: A beacon of h...
      • Pervez Hoodbhoy: Scientists & an atomic subcontine...
      • Ishrat Jahan encounter case: Cops protecting accus...
      • Modi’s Pals: CAG report indicts Gujarat government...
      • Godhra Investigations
      • Bansal or Mamata, top rail job postings reek of ir...
      • India's Child Soldiers: Thousands recruited, Gover...
      • Notes from the frontline of the war in cyberspace
      • Over 900 victims; Dhaka disaster world’s worst in ...
      • Seema Sirohi: As historic elections dawn, public m...
      • Pratap Bhanu Mehta - Phantom democracy
      • Pakistani prisoner Sanaullah Ranjay, who was attac...
      • Three more Tibetans self-immolate
      • A Muslim woman and a Brahmin widow
      • Exclusive interview with Noam Chomsky on Pakistan ...
      • Book review: The identity question - comment on Se...
      • Stephen Hawking joins academic boycott of Israel
      • Tariq Ali - 1963: from the Stones to Dr Strangelov...
      • 'An honest Minister keeps the Railways honest'
      • Narendra Modi magic fails in Karnataka
      • Aarti Tikoo Singh's extended interview with Tarek ...
      • Book review: The trouble with the Enlightenment
      • US Air Force Officer In Charge Of Sexual Assault P...
      • An open letter on undertrials: Adivasis need speed...
      • US panel wants Modi included on lookout list besid...
      • No Mr. Umari, Shahbagh Is No Imperialist Conspirac...
      • 22 dead as Bangladesh Islamists demand blasphemy l...
    • ►  April (100)
    • ►  March (5)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile